Termite
Trails
An Introduction to Scientific Inquiry
This initial lab of the semesters
sets the tone for the student-directed and
inquiry-based nature of this lab experience.
The intent of this lab is to engage students in
the process of doing science and to reveal and
refine/reform their conceptions about the nature
of science and the methods scientists use to study
nature. Lab Summary
In this lab students observe the behavior of
termites exposed to a “trail” made by a black
ballpoint ink pen. After initially
observing the termites' behavior student teams
develop a question they would like to explore
regarding a specific observation. Teams then pose
their own hypothesis, protocol for testing their
hypothesis (using available lab materials), and
predicted results, which would both support and
refute their hypotheses. The lab culminates with
groups presenting their proposal to the
class. These presentations are meant to have
students explore their initial conceptions of how
scientists go about seeking answers to a
biological question. Each presentation is
discussed, weighing the strengths and
weaknesses. Students are asked to rewrite
their proposals based on the class
discussion. The end of lab discussion also
focuses on several reflection questions about key
aspects of scientific discovery (sources of
variation, sampling design, describing data, &
naturalism). Watch
a video of the termite trails by clicking on the
picture.
Scientific
Skills - students will practice and receive
feedback on the following skills:
constructing scientific
hypothesis and experimental prediction
designing an experiment
that controls for variables across treatments and
trials.
designing quantitative
measures of biological features in nature and reflect
on their value with regard to objectivity, precision,
and accuracy.
reflecting on the
purpose of random assignment of subjects to treatments
in order to control for selection bias.
exploring the proper
types of graph to summarize/describe a data set.
drawing a graph which
contains all of the essential features required to
clearly, concisely and comprehensively summarize a
data set (i.e. figure caption, measures of variation,
axis labels, units of measure). reflecting on the importance
of sample size in generalizing results to the
population.
exploring the source of
limitations in the conclusions one can draw from
scientific experiments.
exploring the
difference between naturalistic (scientific) and
non-naturalistic (non-scientific) hypotheses.
Learning Theory & Pedagogy
Learning is an on-going process in which new
understanding is constructed from new information, but
which is tempered by the learners’ prior conceptions
(and misconceptions). Research in cognitive
science also shows that our own familiar and personally
comfortable conceptions often get in the way of
constructing a new, but more accurate
understanding. This is particularly true for
individuals who are novices in the content area being
explored. For these reasons, this initial lab will
allow students to actively explore, reveal, discuss and
correct their own preconceptions about scientific
inquiry by conducting and reflecting on an experiment of
their own design.
Instructional Resources
An instructor guide
which provide lab instructors with pre-lab preparation
instructions, suggested materials, learning theory and
pedagogical suggestions including common conceptions
expressed by students and suggestions for leading the
end of lab class discussion of team proposals.
An opening and engaging
audio case study (from WNYC's Radiolab) intended to
challenge students' conceptions and encourage
deeper considerations of the nature of scientific
hypotheses.
Instructor PowerPoint
presentation which guides students through the
different stages of the lab.